After yesterday’s short piece on the AL MVP, I started thinking about the players who would probably win it in the National League. Unlike the American League, the National League is most likely a race between three different players. Two outfielders and one catcher, if you’ve been following baseball you know of these three young superstars. A case can be made for any of them to win it, but who’s going to be this years National League MVP?
Let’s take a trip down memory lane: Remember when the Pirates held a 1 game lead of the NL Central going into the All Star break? Who ever thought that could ever happen?! Believe it or not, the Pirates were one of the best teams in baseball heading into the All Star break and they had one player to thank for that: Andrew McCutchen. A five-tool player, Cutch was on fire this first half of this season and his performance was certainly worthy of having his name thrown into the NL MVP race. He was batting .362 heading at the break and it looked like the Pirates were on their way to a first winning season in almost 20 years!
Now back to reality: The Pirates are now a .500 team; have a 1.3% chance of making the playoffs; and Cutch’s performance has suffered a little. If there was an award for best first half, Cutch would be a slam dunk to win it. He was clearly the team’s and the league’s most valuable player heading into the All Star break. As of right now, I don’t think that Cutch is going to win it. He should get plenty of top five and even top three votes for MVP, but if Cutch wins it, I’ll be surprised. However, Cutch is going to be a generation player. With only 3 years under his belt in the Majors, we haven’t even seen the best of this young Pittsburgh outfielder. The city of Pittsburgh haven’t had this kind of baseball talent since the early 90s with some guy named Barry Bonds.
If you’re going on pure numbers, there’s this stud in Milwaukee who’s putting up similar, if not better numbers than last season. Ryan Braun, who won last year’s MVP over Matt Kemp in a coin flip vote, is arguably having a better season this year than last year. His average is down a little bit from last year, but he’s still batting .313/.388/.599. Braun has also set career highs in home runs with 40 (which leads the NL), drawn 59 walks, and with 171 hits and 104 RBIs, he’ll most likely set carrer highs in those categories as well. Oh and did I mention that he’s got 27 steals on the season too? One word can describe him: stud.
You know what other word a lot of people use to describe Ryan Braun: cheater. During last off season, news got out that Ryan Braun was tested positive for PEDs aka the Cardinal Sin of ball players. I don’t know about you, but I was devastated when I heard about it. In my eyes, Braun was supposed to be the next great generation of players: a clean generation that resembled baseball in it’s Golden age. Even though, through a series of legal loopholes, his suspension was lifted, there was still a sour taste in my mouth. I suspect that same sour taste will be in the mouths of voters this year and years to come when it comes to Braun. Even though his stats back it up, I’ll be shocked if Mr. Braun repeats this year as the NL MVP, but he should gather a bunch of top 3 votes from writers across the country.
When it comes to important positions on the field, the catcher is one of the most undervalued positions in all of baseball. With the ability to physically call the game, throw runners out on a dime, and take charges from the likes of Prince Fielder at home plate, a catcher who can do all of those things are a dime a dozen. Luckily for San Francisco Giants fans, they have found their franchise catcher in Buster Posey. Having not played since his rookie season two years ago because of a knee injury he sustained earlier last year, many people wrote off Posey this year as an elite catcher. Sure, we all knew he had amazing potential (on both sides of the plate), but I don’t think many people predicted the season he is having right now. Since the all star break Posey’s been playing out of this world. He’s batting close to .400 and is gunning people out from home left and right.
When it comes to the MVP of the year in the NL, it has got to be Buster Posey. Although still young in his career, he’s such an important part of that clubhouse. When he went down last year, the team was absolutely pathetic on offense. They didn’t score nearly as many runs as they did in their World Series run one year previously and looked last luster on defense the entire season. With a healthy Buster Posey behind the plate, the team is rejuvenated and actually considered a one of the teams poised to make a deep October run, even without their normal ace Tim Lincecum who has struggled all year. Catchers aren’t usually considered favorites for the MVP award. Since 1972 only three catchers have won the award (Bench, Munson and Mauer), however I think it’s time the baseball writers to give credit where credit is due.